A gift for the Goddess or an offering for the pond?
Working toward Purple Heart? Hold the gift and hand it to the Goddess. If you’re after the Power Berry, save your offering for a visit when the spring is empty.

When the Goddess is standing by the water
Hold the item, walk up to her, face her and press □ (Square). Her reaction determines the points. A favorite gives 500, a liked gift gives 300 and an ordinary one gives 100. The two negative reactions cost 500 or 800 points. One gift counts per day. If you offer another that day, the second item stays in your hands.
You can still put the item away and talk to her on that visit. The daily conversation and the daily gift have separate counts. If you remapped your keyboard or controller, check which keys DuckStation uses for × and □.
When you’re after the Power Berry
Visit when the Goddess isn’t already standing in the area. Hold your offering, face the pond’s offering spot and use × (Cross) to throw it. This follows the original offering rules, including the requirements for the Power Berry reward. Pond offerings don’t add affection or count toward your direct gift days.
If she’s still there after a cutscene or visiting on her usual schedule, trying to throw an offering brings up a message. You keep the item and neither count changes. Save it for another visit, or walk over and press □ to give it to her in person.
